
Picture by: @Sora Shimazaki
On 1 August 2025, the UK Supreme Court delivered its long-awaited ruling on three test cases examining whether car finance commission arrangements created unfairness in the way loans were structured and sold. The cases of Hopcraft v Close Brothers, Wrench v FirstRand and Johnson v FirstRand were chosen to clarify how the law applies to different types of dealer–lender commission agreements.
The ruling followed years of litigation and a pivotal intervention by the Court of Appeal in 2024, which had already signalled that certain commission models could undermine fairness. That earlier decision fuelled hopes that borrowers might recover significant sums where lenders and dealers had failed to be transparent.
The Hopcrafts’ case involved a fixed commission arrangement. Unlike discretionary commission arrangements (DCAs), where a dealer can raise interest rates to boost their own reward, fixed commissions appear less conflicted. The Supreme Court’s handling of Hopcraft was therefore seen as a crucial test of how far consumer protections might extend to practices that, while not discretionary, still lacked transparency.
Background to the Case
Amy and Carl Hopcraft financed their car purchase through Close Brothers, with the agreement arranged by a dealership. The dealer received a fixed commission for introducing the loan. Importantly, the finance agreement included a short statement saying the dealer may receive a commission. No amount was disclosed, and the document did not explain whether the commission affected the interest rate.
The Hopcrafts argued that this structure made their loan more expensive and that failing to give them full details of the commission was unfair. Their claim was selected to run alongside Wrench and Johnson, giving the Court the chance to compare three different models of commission. These were fixed commission, discretionary commission and discretionary commission with additional aggravating features.
Fixed Commission vs Discretionary Commission
To understand the legal issues, it helps to separate fixed commissions from discretionary commissions.
- Fixed commission : the dealer is paid the same amount regardless of the interest rate charged. The conflict of interest is weaker, but questions remain about disclosure and fairness.
- Discretionary commission (DCA) : the dealer can choose the rate within a range, earning more if they charge you more. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) recognised this as a serious conflict of interest and banned DCAs in January 2021.
The Hopcraft case therefore gave the Supreme Court the opportunity to decide whether a fixed commission was enough to create an “unfair relationship”.
The Legal Arguments in Hopcraft
Bribery and Secret Commission
Under English law, a bribe or civil secret commission arises when a payment is made to an agent without the principal’s informed consent, as established in Hovenden v Millhoff and reaffirmed in FHR European Ventures LLP v Cedar Capital Partners LLC. The key feature of secrecy is that the principal is not fully informed that the agent is being paid.
Application in Hopcraft : because the finance agreement contained wording that the dealer may receive commission, the Court held the payment was not “secret”. That disclosure, although minimal, defeated the bribery argument. Without secrecy, the law of bribes could not apply.
Fiduciary Duty
A fiduciary duty arises where one party must act with loyalty in another’s best interests, for example, solicitors or trustees. Courts have been reluctant to impose fiduciary duties on commercial sales agents, since they are seen as acting in their own business interests.
Application in Hopcraft : the Supreme Court confirmed that a car dealer arranging finance is not automatically a fiduciary. The dealer’s role was commercial in nature, focused on selling cars and finance products. Without an express undertaking to act for the consumer, there was no fiduciary duty breached.
Unfair Relationship under the Consumer Credit Act
The Consumer Credit Act 1974, section 140A allows the court to declare a credit relationship “unfair” because of the terms of the agreement, how it is operated, or any other conduct by the lender or dealer. It is a broad and flexible test, meaning the consumer does not need to prove dishonesty, only unfairness.
Application in Hopcraft : the Court accepted that the disclosure was minimal but found it legally sufficient. With a fixed commission that was not shown to be unusually high, and no evidence of misleading presentation, the arrangement did not cross the threshold into unfairness.
The Supreme Court’s Decision
The Supreme Court ruled against the Hopcrafts. It concluded that the short wording in their contract of the possibility of receiving a commission was enough to put them on notice. Because of this, the commission was not “secret” in law, and the payment did not amount to a bribe.
The Court also confirmed that a fixed commission, on its own, is not inherently unfair. Unless the commission is exceptionally high or presented in a way that misleads the consumer about lender choice, the courts are unlikely to find that the relationship is unfair under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974.
This meant the Hopcrafts’ claim failed, even though they had not been told the exact amount of commission or how it related to their loan costs.
How Hopcraft Differs from the Other Test Cases
The Hopcraft ruling is best understood in the wider context of the three cases heard together:
- Wrench v FirstRand : concerned a discretionary commission arrangement (DCA), where the dealer could vary the interest rate. The Court found disclosure wording blocked the bribery claim, and no fiduciary duty applied. The case failed.
- Johnson v FirstRand : also involved a DCA, but here the commission was extraordinarily high (about 55% of the total credit cost) and disclosure was poor. The Court ruled this created an “unfair relationship”, ordering repayment of the commission with interest.
- Hopcraft v Close Brothers : showed that with a fixed commission and minimal disclosure, the Court did not consider the arrangement unfair.
Taken together, these cases show that context matters. A DCA may still give rise to a claim if combined with aggravating features (as in Johnson), while fixed commissions are harder to challenge unless unusually large or hidden in misleading terms.
Key Lessons for Consumers
The Hopcraft case shows how disclosure wording can make or break a claim. Even a vague line in the contract mentioning commission was enough for the Court to dismiss arguments of secrecy, making fixed commission agreements much harder to challenge unless additional unfair factors are present.
Curious about what extra factors can turn a finance deal into an ‘unfair relationship’? Explore our detailed breakdown here.
The FCA’s Role After the Judgment
On 3 August 2025, the Financial Conduct Authority confirmed that it will establish an industry-wide redress scheme focusing on discretionary commission arrangements. This means that while many claims like the Hopcrafts’ may fail in court, millions of drivers with DCA-based agreements could still receive compensation through the FCA-led process.
Find out what the FCA’s new redress scheme could mean for drivers, lenders, and the car finance market in our full analysis.
What to Watch in Your Finance Agreement
The Hopcraft decision is a reminder that not every commission creates a legal right to redress.
If you are entering into a new finance agreement, make sure you ask:
- Will the dealer receive commission, and how much?
- Does this affect the interest rate you are offered?
- Are you free to compare finance deals with other lenders?
Defending Your Rights is Our Mission
At Consumer Rights Solicitors, we believe that every driver has the right to a fair deal, free from hidden incentives that raise costs without consent.
We offer :
- Free initial assessments
- Clear, practical advice on whether your finance terms may be unfair
- No Win No Fee representation for eligible claims
If you suspect your past finance deal included unfair commissions, contact us today.
Our experienced legal team can help you understand your rights and explore whether you could still claim redress.





